August 2026 | Location: Starke, FL (Bradford County) | Completed by: Jonathan Thiele, J&M Roofing’s St. Augustine Branch
There is a version of this project that involves a demolition crew, a fleet of dumpsters, 18,000 square feet of metal panels hauled to a landfill, and a building that cannot operate normally for weeks. That version was never necessary. Ron’s facility in Starke had a sound metal roof that was leaking at its weak points, not failing as a structure — so on August 31, 2026, Jonathan Thiele and the J&M Roofing St. Augustine crew restored it instead, cleaning and detailing 180 squares of low-slope corrugated metal and sealing the whole thing under a GAF high-solids silicone coating system.
Location: Starke, FL — Bradford County (32091)
Installation Date: August 31, 2026
J&M Roofing Specialist: Jonathan Thiele — St. Augustine Branch Lead
Property Type: Commercial / institutional building
Roof Style: Low-slope corrugated metal, broad twin planes with a central ridge
Roof Pitch: 1/12
Roof Size: 180 squares — roughly 18,000 square feet
System: GAF high-solids silicone roof coating over the existing metal roof
Scope: Full surface preparation, fastener and seam detailing, coated monolithic finish
Method: Restoration — no tear-off, no roof replacement
Metal roofs on commercial buildings rarely wear out the way people expect. The panels themselves often have decades of service left when a building starts taking on water. What gives out first is everything holding the system together: the fasteners and the seams.
Both are casualties of movement. Metal expands and contracts with every temperature swing, and in North Florida that cycle runs daily and year-round. Over thousands of cycles, exposed fasteners work loose and their rubber washers harden, crack, and stop sealing. Panel laps shift against each other and open microscopic gaps. Add a 1/12 pitch like this one — barely any slope at all — and water does not race off the roof the way it would on a steep one. It lingers, finds every compromised fastener and seam, and goes in.
That is why a restoration can be the right answer where a replacement would be overkill. The roof’s problem is not the metal. It is the thousands of individual penetrations and joints across its surface. A coating system addresses exactly that: prepare the surface, treat every fastener and every seam individually, then unify the entire roof under a continuous membrane with no fasteners and no laps to fail.
The caveat matters as much as the pitch. Restoration only works on a roof with sound structure and sound panels. Where metal is badly corroded through, where decking or framing is compromised, or where insulation below is saturated, coating over the problem buries it rather than fixing it. The inspection is what decides, and an honest contractor will tell a building owner when a roof does not qualify.
Roof coatings are not interchangeable. Acrylic, silicone, and urethane systems each behave differently, and the pitch of this roof pointed clearly at one of them.
Silicone’s defining strength is how it handles standing water. Acrylic coatings are water-based and can soften and re-emulsify where water sits for extended periods — which is a real problem on a nearly flat roof where ponding is a fact of life rather than a defect. Silicone does not. It cures into a membrane that tolerates ponding water indefinitely, which is why it is the standard recommendation for low-slope applications like this 1/12.
Silicone also holds up to ultraviolet exposure better than most alternatives. A coated roof is, by definition, the most sun-exposed surface on the property, and in Florida that exposure is relentless. Silicone weathers it without the chalking and embrittlement that shortens the life of lesser systems.
The “high-solids” part is about how much of what goes into the sprayer stays on the roof. Coating products are a mix of solids and carrier; the carrier evaporates and the solids remain as the finished membrane. A high-solids formulation leaves more material behind per gallon applied, which means the specified dry film thickness is achieved in fewer passes, with less product, and in less time on the roof. On an 18,000-square-foot surface, that efficiency is the difference between a manageable project and a long one.
Starke sits at the junction of US-301 and SR-16 in Bradford County, the seat of a small North Florida county between Gainesville and Jacksonville, near Camp Blanding and surrounded by pine country and farmland. The buildings that serve a community like this one — schools, civic facilities, light industrial and institutional properties — tend to be exactly what Ron’s building is: long, wide, single-story, and metal-roofed, with far more roof than wall.
The site conditions in the photos tell the rest. The building sits on open ground with mowed field on every side, a second metal-roofed structure nearby, and a transmission tower beyond the property line. There is no surrounding development and no tree canopy to break anything. Wind arrives across open country with nothing to slow it, and the roof takes unobstructed sun from first light to last.
That exposure is what makes the reflective finish more than cosmetic. A bright silicone surface on 18,000 square feet reflects a substantial share of solar energy that a weathered, oxidized metal roof would otherwise absorb and pass into the building. On a facility this size, that reduction in heat load is felt in the cooling system every afternoon of a North Florida summer.
For a commercial or institutional property, the disruption of a roof replacement is often a bigger obstacle than the price. A tear-off means noise directly overhead, debris containment, open roof deck above occupied space, equipment and dumpsters consuming the parking area, and a schedule measured in weeks. For a building that has to stay in use, that is not a minor inconvenience.
A restoration removes almost all of it. Nothing is demolished, so there is no debris stream and no point at which the interior is exposed. The work stays on top of the roof. Occupants below experience far less disruption than they would during a replacement, and the building keeps functioning throughout.
Sequence is what makes it work: the roof is cleaned down to a sound surface, rust and problem areas are addressed, every exposed fastener is treated, seams and laps are detailed and reinforced, and only then is the field coated to the specified thickness. In the photos, you can see that detail work directly — the ridge and every panel lap coated in heavy bands before the broad field was brought up to full coverage. Skipping that preparation is how coating projects fail, because the membrane is only as good as what it bonds to.
Jonathan Thiele leads J&M Roofing’s St. Augustine branch with more than seven years in roofing, holding certifications across GAF, CertainTeed, and IKO systems along with GAF metal roofing and Fortified credentials. The metal credential is the relevant one here: knowing how metal roofs are built, fastened, and how they move is what allows a specialist to judge whether a roof is a restoration candidate or genuinely needs replacing.
That judgment is the most valuable thing on a project like this. A building owner facing a leaking roof is usually handed a replacement quote and a long schedule, and the honest question — whether the roof’s structure is sound enough to restore instead — often goes unasked. Jonathan also previously held a Florida 6-20 All Lines Adjuster License, which gives him practical familiarity with how roof conditions get documented and evaluated. Commercial restoration work out of our St. Augustine branch reaches well across North Florida, and property owners who want a straight answer can call our commercial roofing contractors directly.
The finished roof reads as a continuous bright white-gray surface running the full length of both planes, with the ridge detailed in a heavy coated band and every panel lap visibly sealed. The fastener heads that were the roof’s weak points are now encapsulated rather than exposed. From the ridge, the coating runs unbroken to each eave with no seams and no penetrations left untreated.
What Ron’s facility gained is a roof that stopped leaking without the building ever closing. The existing metal stayed in place and out of a landfill, the interior was never opened to the sky, and 180 squares of aging roof now sit under a reflective, seamless silicone membrane rated for the ponding water a 1/12 pitch guarantees. For a building that has to stay open and a roof that was structurally fine, that is the proportionate answer.
System: GAF high-solids silicone roof coating
Substrate: Existing corrugated metal roof, retained in place
Roof Size: 180 squares — roughly 18,000 square feet
Roof Pitch: 1/12 — low slope
Roof Style: Broad twin planes meeting at a central ridge
Scope: Surface preparation and cleaning, rust and problem-area treatment, individual fastener detailing, seam and lap reinforcement, coated monolithic field
Method: Restoration — no tear-off, no replacement, no disruption to building operations
Performance: Ponding-water tolerant, UV stable, highly reflective finish
Property Type: Commercial / institutional building
Site Conditions: Open rural ground, no surrounding canopy, full sun and unobstructed wind exposure
Location: Starke, FL — Bradford County (32091)
Specialist: Jonathan Thiele — J&M Roofing St. Augustine Branch Lead
Installation Date: August 31, 2026
Branch: St. Augustine — (904) 320-1968
Before you accept a replacement quote on a commercial metal roof, find out whether the metal is actually the problem. If the panels and structure are sound and the leaks are coming from fasteners and seams, a silicone restoration can solve it without a tear-off, without debris, and without shutting the building down. If the roof does not qualify, you deserve to hear that plainly too. We inspect and restore commercial metal roofs across Starke, Lake City, Gainesville, Jacksonville, and North Florida.
Call our St. Augustine office at (904) 320-1968, Monday through Friday, 9am to 5pm, for a free estimate and roof inspection.
